Travel for women and their friends


 


Countries
Weddings
With The Kids
Travelling Fat
Our Newsletter
Home


Begging Questions

What are you really doing when you give a child a dollar?

by Mary Ann Christie

"Buy for one dollar Lady?"

Normally, the sight of a waif in torn clothing would send my heart into a tumble and my hand reaching for my wallet. In Ensenada, Mexico, I'd been lucky enough to have been on a tour with Lili, a local guide who explained the importance of not giving in to these instincts. Lili told my group that the minimum wage in Ensenada was $8.00/day and that a person had to work very hard when making that small amount of money. She let us know that in Mexico it was not mandatory to send children to school and that the families who ran the "Chicklet Kid" industry were in the business of exploiting their own children for money. We would not be doing any of these children, who ranged in age from about 3 years old to teens, a favor. We would be encouraging these families to keep having babies that they could exploit as shills for them. That information made it easier to steel myself for the trip along the market where I was stopped almost every step by a plaintive cry.

Tiny children wandered after tourists asking over and over for money. They had been well coached. The little girl who followed me through half the market started by asking for a dollar for wind chimes. She dropped that to 50 cents and then she simply asked for a quarter, a nickel, "just a penny for me lady? Just a penny?". I took a hard look at this little girl. She appeared to be about 9 and there was no joy in her face as she looked into my eyes. She should have been in school with her peers at that moment, her childhood grooming her for a fulfilling life. What would this childhood groom her for? Would she become a breeder of begging children who would continue this vicious cycle?

Lili, our guide, who loves Mexico with a passion that's very evident, showed me Ensenada through her eyes and there was so much to be proud of. There are jobs for any who want them and fewer people have to settle for minimum wage jobs these days. But she was very plain in her anger towards people who would deprive their children of an education and send them out on the streets to beg for money. She told us that her next door neighbors are a couple who "work the tourists". The live on a middle class street and have a baby each year. The mother goes to the market with the children and they sell chick let gum and shell wind chimes for as much as a tourist will pay. Lili feels that this practice makes her Mexico look bad....I would have to agree with her because I knew about the chick let kids long before I arrived in Ensenada, but I didn't know about the economy or the very good public education system.

I didn't give the little girl a penny. I won't be melting at the sight of these children from now on. I'll take Lili's advice and hand them a sandwich or a treat, something for them that won't go to line the pockets of parents who see raising children as an industry.

The articles contained on Chicktrip are the exclusive property of Chicktrip. Do not reproduce this material on any other website or publication. You are welcome to link.

Contact Webmaster

©2005